Canyon de Chelly North Rim Drive – Massacre Cave Overlook

Author's Comments

Some places are difficult to photograph because the weight of what happened there sits heavier than the light. Massacre Cave is one of them. The overlook gives you a long view down into Canyon del Muerto, and the alcove itself is visible across the gulf in the opposite wall, a dark recess in the sandstone where in 1805 a great many Navajo lost their lives. You learn this before you arrive, and you cannot unlearn it once you are standing there. The canyon does not perform for you here. It simply opens. The walls drop in long vertical sweeps of red and ochre, layered in a way that feels less like geology and more like time made visible. Morning is the hour, before the sun climbs high enough to flatten the strata. The east-facing walls catch warm light first while the canyon floor stays in shadow, and that contrast is where the photograph lives. A wide lens. A long pause before you raise the camera. I have stood at this overlook in late October when the cottonwoods on the canyon floor were turning, and the color was so far below me it read almost as a rumor. Winter strips the place further. There is a stillness here that the more famous overlooks on the South Rim do not have, partly because fewer people make the drive out, and partly because the cave itself asks something of you that the rest of the canyon does not. Stay a while. Let the wind do what it does. The picture you make will be quieter than you expected, and that is the right register for this particular piece of ground.

Gallery